Delhi HC Quashes Criminal Defamation Case Against Pinaki Misra Over 'Crook' Remark Against Lawyer

Delhi HC Quashes Criminal Defamation Case Against Pinaki Misra Over 'Crook' Remark Against Lawyer

The Delhi High Court has quashed criminal defamation proceedings against Senior Advocate and former Biju Janata Dal (BJD) MP Pinaki Misra over an alleged defamatory remark describing a fellow lawyer as a “crook”.

Justice Sachin Datta held that the complainant, advocate Siddhartha Singh, had failed to place any material before the trial court to prima facie establish that the alleged remark had lowered his reputation in the estimation of others, as required under the law of criminal defamation.

The Court accordingly set aside the trial court's April 2019 summoning order and quashed the criminal defamation complaint against Misra.

The High Court also observed that the trial court had failed to examine the context in which the alleged remark was made and the fact that the Bar Council of Delhi had already dismissed the professional misconduct complaint filed by Singh against Misra.

The dispute arose from an August 2018 report published by The Economic Times concerning a complaint filed by Singh before the Bar Council of Delhi. Singh had accused Misra of professional misconduct, alleging a conflict of interest arising from his appearance before the National Green Tribunal (NGT) on behalf of power distribution companies.

At the relevant time, Misra was a Member of Parliament and chaired the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Urban Development. Singh objected to his appearance for the power distribution companies, claiming that the parliamentary committee headed by Misra had made adverse recommendations concerning those companies.

Following the publication of the report, Misra was allegedly quoted as describing Singh as a “crook”. Aggrieved by the remark, Singh issued a legal notice demanding an unconditional apology before initiating criminal defamation proceedings against him.

While examining the complaint, the High Court noted that Singh had examined himself as the sole witness before the trial court. However, he had neither identified nor examined any person who had read the newspaper report and could establish that the alleged statement had adversely affected their perception of his reputation.

The Court further took note of the fact that the Bar Council of Delhi had dismissed Singh's professional misconduct complaint against Misra in November 2018.

It also referred to a connected criminal defamation case arising out of a report published on Dailyhunt, which had already been quashed by the High Court in August 2026.

Senior Advocate Rebecca John, along with advocate Anushka Baruah, appeared for Misra. Additional Public Prosecutor Aashneet Singh represented the State.

Share this News

Website designed, developed and maintained by webexy