The Supreme Court has held that no voter or candidate has a vested right to have a particular constituency reserved for Scheduled Caste (SC) or Scheduled Tribe (ST) candidates. The Court also observed that the State government has the discretion to decide the manner and timing of rotation of reserved constituencies.
A Bench of Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana dismissed a petition challenging Rule 12 of the Maharashtra Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis (Manner and Rotation of Reservation of Seats) Rules, 2025.
The petitioner had earlier approached the Bombay High Court, challenging the Rule as arbitrary and unconstitutional under Article 14 of the Constitution. However, the High Court dismissed the plea, observing that no person could claim a right to have a particular constituency reserved.
During the hearing before the Supreme Court, Senior Advocate Vipin Sanghi, appearing for the petitioner, argued that Rule 12 had made the concept of rotation meaningless.
He submitted that the petitioner's constituency had never been reserved. However, just when it was due for reservation, the authorities decided to start the rotation process afresh.
He argued that this could mean that the constituency might never get an opportunity to be reserved.
Responding to the submission, Justice Bagchi observed that the mechanism for rotation under the relevant rules and Article 243(r) of the Constitution was within the State government's discretion.
“Rule 4(2) of 1961 Rules and Article 243(r) speak of rotation but the mechanism of rotation is within the discretion of the state government and that is where Rule 12 is within the jurisdiction of the state government,” the judge remarked.
Sanghi clarified that the petitioner was not challenging the validity of the Rule but was questioning the decision to restart the rotation process just when the petitioner's constituency was due to be reserved.
Justice Bagchi then questioned whether a voter or candidate could claim a right to have a particular constituency reserved.
“Do you have a right to have your constituency reserved? No. It is the cutoff date. It can always be shifted by the government,” the judge observed.
No Vested Right To Reservation In Particular Constituency: Supreme Court
In its order, the Bench observed that neither voters nor candidates could claim a vested right to have a particular constituency reserved.
The Court clarified that the Constitution and the relevant rules provide for reservation of seats in proportion to the SC/ST population in the concerned local body.
It noted that reserved seats are to be rotated according to the descending order of the SC/ST population. However, the manner and time frame for carrying out the reservation and rotation are within the State government's discretion.
The Bench further noted that the State government had decided under Rule 12 to treat the next election after the 2025 amendment as the first election for the purpose of rotation.
“We find no reason to hold that said Rule runs counter to either the concept of reservation of rotation of seats,” the Court held.
Accordingly, the Supreme Court dismissed the petition. However, it clarified that the dismissal would not prevent the petitioner from making a representation to the State government seeking reconsideration of the scheme for rotation of reserved seats in accordance with law.
Case Title: Sau. Rupali Indrabhushan Sonde @ Ku. Rupali Sharadrao Badhiye v. The State of Maharashtra
Case No.: Diary No. 68024/2026
Website designed, developed and maintained by webexy